America's Interests and
the U.N.
from a speech by John Bolton, former U.S.
Ambassador to the United Nations
April 2008 issue of Imprimis
"Norming" is the
idea that the U.S. should base its decisions on
some kind of international consensus, rather
than making its decisions as a constitutional
democracy The argument is "one nation, one
vote," best expressed by one U.S. critic who
avers, "The problem with the United States is
its devotion to its Constitution over
international norms."
Bolton cites as
an example the death penalty which has
been ruled out by the U.N. and which led to
threats of impeachment against South Korea's Ban
ki-moon, the Secretary General, when he said
each country should decide for itself. (South
Korea still has the death penalty.)
Then there is
gun control. During a discussion about the
illicit flow of weapons into conflict areas of
the world,"We were not going to sign on to any
international agreement that prohibits private
ownership of guns. I explained that we have a
Constitution that precluded any such
restrictions. This was treated as an entirely
specious notion."
"Although the
U.N. is perfectly capable of passing resolutions
about the death penalty and gun control -- not
to mention smoking -- it has proved utterly
incapable, even after 9/11, of agreeing to a
definition of terrorism . . . because several
member governments think there is a good
terrorism and a bad terrorism."
The U.N. Budget
Committee voted two to one against effective
outside auditing of U.N. programs.
Under the current
system, the U.S. pays 22% of the cost of most
U.N. agencies, and 27% of peacekeeping costs. We
are by far the largest contributor.
"There is one
point of view here in America -- a view given
expression during the 2004 presidential campaign
by Senator Kerry -- holding that American
foreign policy should meet some kind of 'global
test . . . to demonstrate the legitimacy of its
foreign policy decisions by getting the
approval of the U.N. Security Council or some
other international body
"The same
suggestion will no doubt surface again in the
run-up to the November election." |