Candidates' Post-election Comments

Post-election comments by the candidates in the 2007 Election appear in the left column in the order they were received.


Brian James
Many thanks from me to the folks who worked so hard on this campaign. It is important for people to have choices and the efforts of the volunteers were an integral part of that. Throughout the election process the residents have demonstrated time and again by their concerns and questions that they want Royal Oak to thrive. Everyday by keeping their homes and neighborhoods in excellent condition the residents express a continuing vote of confidence in each other and in their community.

My fervent wish is that city government will reflect the values of the majority of Royal Oak residents to the benefit of all as opposed to reflecting only the special interests of the few. If the new City Commission can meet that challenge, then the residents will benefit greatly.


Andrew Androff
Thank You Royal Oak

It was a privilege and honor coming to know so many of you during this campaign. I did my best to express our vision and our hopes for Royal Oak. Together, we worked hard and we fought hard, and although I wish that things had turned out a little differently, I can confidently say the future of our community is in great hands. We have an immensely talented City Commission and Mayor that will serve our community with great leadership and vision. The next few years will be a challenging and exciting time for our community. Now more than ever it is time that we must remain involved and committed to helping our city any way we can. I urge and ask residents to continue to volunteer and share your ideas.

There's so much that goes into a campaign and there's so much that residents never get to see. I will be the first to tell you that I owe so much to my family. They were with me every single step of the way. No one has been more selfless and supportive and demonstrated more grace, courage and candor, than my wife Katie. She has made our home a happy one and managed to help run my business, plan our wedding, and put up with the highs and lows that one experiences during a run for any political office.

My brother Don, a now seasoned campaign manager, who committed a full year of his life to helping me hurdle the challenges of an unknown world. You taught me so much about being committed. We left nothing on the table and we did everything we humanly could so that win or lose we would never have regrets or the thought that we could of tried harder.

I want to thank my family, friends, and neighbors who stood outside each precinct to help distribute our campaign message. You withstood freezing weather and you represented me with such vigor and unwavering support.

I would like to thank the residents of Royal Oak. In our journey, you have given me the gift to listen and learn from you. I've heard your stories. I know your struggles, I know your hopes. They are part of me now. And I will never forget you and I'll never stop fighting for you.

I thank Frank Versagi and Ryan Shelby who have provided our community with fair and non-biased mediums for all candidates to present ideas.

I would like to thank the Royal Oak Police Officers Association who gave me their endorsement and took a chance on a new kid. It made for an ironic and funny headline when one of my moving trucks was stolen on Election Day from behind my home. You guys are true heroes to our community and I am happy to report to everyone that the truck was recovered later that night. So, from me and my insurance carrier, thank you very much for a job well done.

Finally, I would like to thank every candidate. I have enjoyed getting to know each of you. Jim, Art, Brian, Mitzi, Terry, Clyde, Chuck, and Mike, you all brought important ideas and issues forward that will make Royal Oak a better place.

In this election, there were no losers, because whether your candidates were successful or not, the next morning we all woke up as one community. Royal Oak is and will continue to be the greatest community that anyone could ever call home. Hold on tight to your dreams.



Clyde Esbri
I wanted to take a moment and congratulate winners Chuck, Mike and Terry. I mean it sincerely when I say, I know our city will be well served by the three of you. I look forward to hearing lively discussions at the table as they pertain to our budget. In the light of ever decreasing state revenue sharing, block grant money going away, and the reality of homeowners lining up like they never have in the past looking for property tax relief, the economic challenges our city faces are certainly considerable.

Unlike the candidates who said they flat out will not discuss any tax increase, I stated it publicly more than once, and I'm sure it may have contributed to my unsuccessful bid for office, but I would have put a Headlee over-ride on the ballot before voting at the table to fundamentally change how we offer public safety services to the citizens of Royal Oak. I still feel strongly that removing local control of our fire, police and emergency services and going to a regionally based service changes the very core of what Royal Oak is.I listened closely at a debate held by my neighborhood association, where one of the successful candidates stated, he ably oversaw the regionalization of our solid waste disposal services and therefore saw no reason why a similar approach couldn’t be applied to police and fire services.

I would suggest that trash disposal and recycling services are not parallel to police, fire and emergency response services, therefore parallel logic ought not be applied. I’m not suggesting that our emergency services can’t be regionalized, they can be. I’m suggesting, I want to live in a city where those vital services are controlled locally. Royal Oak is a large enough city where local control is economically viable well into the future. The citizens should be given the opportunity to decide how they want those services delivered and to tell the city commission if they are willing to pay them.

To Art, Mitzi and Andrew, thank you for making this a great experience for me. You guys are great and it was my pleasure getting to know you all.  


Mitzi Hoffman

There is life after "The Campaign."

I would like to take this opportunity to thank all my friends, family and other supporters for assisting me with my campaign for the Royal Oak City Commissioner position. Although the numbers showed that I was not successful in my stated goal, the rewards were many. I met many wonderful people, heard encouraging words from individuals and groups from all "walks of life" here in the city. And for all of that I am grateful. It ended up that the best day of the campaign was Election Day, as I had my son to hang out with, hold my signs, make phone calls, and offer encouraging words, even when the results were available. That helped me get my priorities in order.

I am going to take some time to focus back on taking care of myself, which is difficult to do when you are in the beginning, middle and end of a campaign. I will remain active in city affairs. There is unfinished business.

 
Thanks to you Frank. I'm glad we had a chance to meet and get to know each other a little better. I appreciate the opportunity to use Versagi Voice to distribute my message.

Chuck Semchena
All seven candidates who ran in last week’s city commission election conducted clean and positive campaigns that focused on issues. This provided Royal Oak voters with plenty of information from which to make informed choices. I congratulate my peers for adhering to substance and not launching petty personal attacks. They can all hold their heads high. 

Sadly, the same can’t be said for Oakland County Commissioner Dave Woodward (D-Royal Oak), who as chairman of the Oakland County Democratic Party authored a letter sent to hundreds of voters that attempted to smear my record as the former Royal Oak City Attorney.

I’ve followed Royal Oak politics for more than 20 years, and this is the first time a political party has played such an active and negative role in a non-partisan race. But voters ignored Woodward’s slimy tactic, and it’s ironic that the only city commission candidate who was attacked actually won a seat. The city commission candidates whom Woodward supported lost the election. 

Constituents deserve – and should expect – better behavior from their Oakland County Commissioner.

Because the letter didn’t achieve its objective, I hope Woodward gets the message that Royal Oakers reject negative and partisan tactics. Thus far, he’s refused to apologize for his actions. Perhaps, as Woodward reflects on the election results, it will eventually sink in. But I’m not holding my breath.


    

 

 

 

 

Chuck Semchena

Mitzi Hoffman

Clyde Esbri

Andrew Androff

Brian James